CozySpruce

Kitchen

Open Shelving vs. Cabinets in a Small Kitchen: An Honest Comparison

Open shelves make a small kitchen feel bigger and cost less, but they collect dust and grease and hold less. Here's an honest comparison of open shelving vs. cabinets, smart hybrid layouts, and the shelf sizes that actually work.

By Cozy Spruce EditorsOctober 22, 20268 min readSave to Pinterest
Small kitchen with two wood open shelves holding white dishes beside white upper cabinets

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

The short version: open shelving makes a small kitchen feel bigger and brighter and usually costs less than upper cabinets, but it holds less, shows clutter, and collects dust and kitchen grease. For most small kitchens the best answer is a hybrid: closed cabinets for the bulk of your storage and one or two open shelves for the dishes and glasses you use every day.

Here's an honest side-by-side comparison, followed by the sizes and layouts that make open shelves practical.

Our Top Picks

  1. 1

    Strongest: Heavy-Duty Shelf Brackets, 10 in

    Dishes are heavy, and visible brackets screwed into studs are the sturdiest DIY option.

    See on Amazon
  2. 2

    Don't Skip: Electronic Stud Finder by Zircon

    Every shelf should hang from studs, so find and mark them before you drill.

    See on Amazon
  3. 3

    Solid Wood Floating Shelves, 36 in

    For the clean bracket-free look; check the weight rating against what you'll store.

    See on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Open Shelving vs. Cabinets at a Glance

FactorOpen shelvingUpper cabinets
CostUsually lower (boards and brackets)Higher, especially custom
Storage capacityLess; items can't stack high or hideMore, including deep and odd items
Dust and greaseExposed; needs regular wiping, worse near the rangeProtected behind doors
Visual spaceOpens up the wall, feels largerCan feel heavy in a small room
Clutter toleranceLow; everything is on displayHigh; doors hide mismatched items
AccessFast, no doors to openSlower, but tidier
Renter-friendlySometimes (with permission for wall anchors)Rarely changeable
StyleFarmhouse, Scandinavian, cottageWorks with every style

If you cook a lot of fried or sautéed food, keep open shelves away from the range. Grease and steam settle on anything nearby, so the shelf beside the stove becomes the one you're always wiping.

Types of Open Shelving

TypeLookStrengthNotes
Bracket shelvesClassic farmhouse, visible hardwareStrong when screwed into studsEasiest DIY option; brackets become part of the style
Floating shelvesClean, minimal, no visible supportDepends on the hidden bracket and wallCheck the weight rating carefully for dishes
Rail or pipe shelvesIndustrial, vintageStrongGood for hanging mugs and utensils too
Plate racksCottage, traditionalModerateStores plates upright, saves depth
Glass-front cabinetsA middle groundLike any cabinetShows dishes while keeping dust out

If you like the open look but hate dusting, glass-front upper cabinets are worth considering: you still see your dishes, but doors keep grease and dust out.

When Open Shelving Makes Sense

  • Your kitchen feels dark or cramped and the upper cabinets crowd a window.
  • You own a matching set of everyday dishes you're happy to see.
  • You have enough closed storage elsewhere: lower cabinets, a pantry or a hutch.
  • You're on a tight budget and replacing all the uppers isn't realistic. See our small kitchen remodel on a budget.

When Cabinets Are the Better Choice

  • Your kitchen is your only storage for food, small appliances and bulk items.
  • The shelves would sit next to the range or above a busy prep zone.
  • You don't want weekly dusting.
  • You prefer a calm, closed look with nothing on display.

The Hybrid Layout (Best of Both)

Kitchen with closed cabinets on one side of a window and open shelves on the other

Most small kitchens do best with a mix:

  1. Keep closed cabinets for 70–80% of storage, especially near the range and for pantry items.
  2. Add one or two open shelves in a spot away from the cooktop, often beside or above the sink, or in a corner.
  3. Store everyday items on the open shelves: the plates, bowls, glasses and mugs you wash and put back daily stay dust-free because they're always in use.

This gives you the airy look without giving up the storage a small kitchen needs. For more storage ideas, see our list of small kitchen ideas.

Sizing Open Shelves So They Work

DetailTypical guideline
Shelf depth10–12 in (fits most dinner plates)
Shelf thickness1.5–2 in looks substantial on longer runs
Space between shelvesAbout 14–18 in
Lowest shelf above counterAbout 18–20 in, similar to upper cabinets
Bracket spacingInto studs, typically 16 in apart; at least every 24–32 in
Shelf lengthShort runs (24–48 in) sag less and look lighter

Walnut shelf on black steel brackets with bowls and mugs

Dishes are heavy. Screw brackets into wall studs or use anchors rated well above the load you'll put on the shelf, and follow the bracket maker's weight rating. Tile and old plaster need the right drill bit and care to avoid cracking.

What to Store Where

Open shelvesClosed cabinets
Everyday plates, bowls, glasses, mugsFood, snacks and pantry items
Cookbooks you actually useSmall appliances
A plant or two and a crock of utensilsPlastic containers and lids
Serving bowls you use weeklyCleaning supplies and bulk items

Open shelf styled with bowls, glasses, wooden spoons and a small herb

Keeping Open Shelves Looking Good

  • Group by type and color: stacks of white plates and rows of matching glasses read as calm.
  • Leave about a third of the shelf empty so it doesn't look crowded.
  • Wipe weekly with warm soapy water; a range hood that vents outside helps a lot.
  • Edit seasonally: if something hasn't been used in a month, it belongs behind a door.

Installing Open Shelves: The Basic Steps

  1. Empty and remove the upper cabinet, if you're replacing one, and patch the wall.
  2. Find and mark the studs with a stud finder.
  3. Mark a level line for each shelf, checking height against your tallest plates and glasses.
  4. Mount the brackets into studs with screws long enough for the load; use the right anchors for any bracket that can't hit a stud.
  5. Set and secure the shelf to the brackets so it can't slide off.
  6. Load gradually, heaviest items near the brackets.

If removing cabinets exposes unpainted wall or a gap in the backsplash, plan for tile or paint touch-ups before the shelves go up.

Open Shelving in Rentals

Most leases require permission to drill into walls. Ask your landlord, offer to patch the holes when you move out, and keep the original cabinets if you remove any. Lightweight freestanding options, like a narrow bakers rack or a rolling cart, give you some of the open look with no drilling at all.

Products for Open Shelving

Strongest

Heavy-Duty Shelf Brackets, 10 in

Dishes are heavy, and visible brackets screwed into studs are the sturdiest DIY option.

  • ✓Supports dish weight
  • ✓Mount into studs
  • ✓Matte black or brass finishes
Check Price on Amazon
Don't Skip

Zircon

Electronic Stud Finder

Every shelf should hang from studs, so find and mark them before you drill.

  • ✓Locates studs behind drywall
  • ✓Edge detection
  • ✓Simple to use
Check Price on Amazon

Solid Wood Floating Shelves, 36 in

For the clean bracket-free look; check the weight rating against what you'll store.

  • ✓Clean, bracket-free look
  • ✓Check the weight rating
  • ✓Pre-finished options
Check Price on Amazon

Anchor Hocking

Glass Kitchen Canisters, Set

Matching jars make open shelves look tidy instead of cluttered.

  • ✓Tidy, uniform look
  • ✓Airtight lids
  • ✓See contents at a glance
Check Price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Bottom Line

Open shelving vs. cabinets isn't an all-or-nothing choice. Open shelves cost less and make a small kitchen feel bigger, but they hold less and need regular cleaning. Keep closed cabinets for most storage and near the range, add one or two 10–12 inch deep shelves for everyday dishes, and anchor them into studs. You'll get the open, farmhouse feel of kitchens like our small farmhouse kitchens without sacrificing the storage you need.

Keep Reading